Bauman, Elias and Latour on Modernity and Its Alternatives

Bauman, Elias and Latour on Modernity and Its Alternatives

Three Contemporary Sociological Theorists on Modernity and Other Options

By Sandro Segre

‘Bauman, Elias and Latour on Modernity and Its Alternatives’ summarizes and compares the sociological works of three contemporary authors insofar as they deal with the themes of modernity and its alternatives. These alternatives are either deemed to be possible or actually experienced, whether historically or in the present.

PDF, 114 Pages

ISBN:9781785273056

March 2020

£36.00, $64.00

EPUB, 114 Pages

ISBN:9781785273063

March 2020

£36.00, $64.00

  • About This Book
  • Reviews
  • Author Information
  • Series
  • Table of Contents
  • Links

About This Book

‘Bauman, Elias and Latour on Modernity and Its Alternatives’ provides a synopsis of and comparison between the conceptions of modernity and its alternatives, as found in the works of Bauman, Elias and Latour. Bauman and Elias share a few relevant features bearing on their conceptions of modernity and its possible alternatives; Latour, on the other hand, when compared to these sociologists, is a maverick thinker. The set of alternatives is as follows: modernity vs. post-modernity (Bauman); civilization vs. barbarity (Elias) and successful vs. unsuccessful hybrids (Latour). Bauman’s and Elias’s conceptions of modernity differ in some important respects. The constitutive elements of modernity are, according to Bauman, cognitive order, regulation, stability of relations and identities, and the role of intellectuals as legislators. In Elias’s view, pacification and civilization are the hallmarks of modernity. Both Bauman and Elias maintain, despite their differences, that a condition of barbarity indicates the absence of civilization, but not of modernity.

According to Latour, the scientific usefulness of the concepts of modernity and, by implication, of non-modernity is questionable. If hybrids are defined as heterogeneous associations between humans and non-humans such as instruments and machines, by virtue of their great number they produce a variety of ways in which distinct and incompatible modes of knowledge may be interpreted, defined, and linked. This occurs by means of mediators.

A hybrid condition characterizes the modern world; hence, non-humans are relevant for investigating the modern world as they mediate between nature and society. The latter is a contraposition which Latour rejects, along with those between actor vs. system, science vs. society, nature vs. culture, and humans vs. non-humans. As for this last contraposition, Latour argues that this very distinction results from a process of purification, since humans and non-humans may be actors that form an integrated whole. Modernity therefore results from the two related but opposed processes of hybridization and purification. Much as the very concept of modernity is of questionable usefulness, the concept of non-modernity should also be relinquished. The existence of hybrids makes modernity and non-modernity impossible. In this sense, Latour has contended that we have never been modern. The joint product of human and non-human activities, as resulting in hybrids, may be a failure due, according to Latour, to the mismatch between the human and non-human actors.

Reviews

No reviews for this title.

Author Information

Sandro Segre was professor of sociology and sociological theory at the University of Genoa, Italy, until his retirement in 2015.

Series

No series for this title.

Table of Contents

Preface; 1. Bauman; 2. Elias; 3. Latour; 4. Conclusion; Index.

Links

Latest Tweets

  • 🎉It's finally here!🎉 In MUSIC SCENES AND MIGRATIONS, author David Treece draws attention to the role of the #city… https://t.co/7Jfb7XFgP7

    - 03:11:57 on 03/07/2020
  • RT @TaraVanHo: Grateful @JenaTMartin asked me to be a part of this project aimed at centering the experiences of those whose #humanrights h…

    - 03:11:57 on 03/07/2020
  • "Karen Erica Bravo, @JenaTMartin, and @TaraVanHo brilliantly put #rightsholders back on the map and in the middle o… https://t.co/5D2aMacbSr

    - 03:11:57 on 03/07/2020
  • We're excited to hear Anthem author and @uoregon Prof. @peterlaufer speak about borders, identities, and frontiers.… https://t.co/iNEdgdf5Sy

    - 03:11:57 on 02/07/2020
  • 💸"The truth is that workers pay their taxes while the rich pay very little." HOW AMERICA WAS TRICKED ON TAX POLICY… https://t.co/Dzdiabe1Fd

    - 03:11:57 on 02/07/2020
  • "The problem is not, or not only, those 'bad apples'; it’s the apple barrel—the department as a whole—that tolerate… https://t.co/oji9Bsnqay

    - 03:11:57 on 02/07/2020
  • RT @ColetteGrace: Congratulations to @IdentityWoman as her Kindle volume, The Domains of Identity, published on 06/25 by @AnthemPress as Le…

    - 03:11:57 on 02/07/2020
  • A lot happened in June 2020 and the cycle of information can be overwhelming. Anthem Press has curated 8 note-worth… https://t.co/NCzpn4n5E1

    - 03:11:57 on 01/07/2020
  • 🎉It's finally here!🎉 URBAN CRISIS, URBAN HOPE by Julian Dobson and Rowland Atkinson seeks to reinvigorate a sense… https://t.co/ZH38BFRvbp

    - 03:11:57 on 01/07/2020
  • RT @dharrislawprof: Event is today 6/30 at 5 pm ET/4 pm CT. Could not be more timely. TY @ChicagoKentLaw @PittLaw https://t.co/Jjvnzdy2MW

    - 03:11:57 on 01/07/2020

Comodo SSL