Reaganism in Literary Theory

Reaganism in Literary Theory

Negative Moralism and Hermeneutic Suspicion

By Jeremiah Bowen

Anthem symploke Studies in Theory

Largely erased from disciplinary memory, Paul de Man’s replacement of canon with literariness as the object of literary studies preserved a discourse of devotion and disqualification homologous with Reaganism. This negative moralism shelters professional privilege and competition from scrutiny, supported by misrecognitions like hermeneutic suspicion, materiality, and identity politics.

PDF, 250 Pages

ISBN:9781785272790

July 2020

£25.00, $40.00

EPUB, 250 Pages

ISBN:9781785272806

July 2020

£25.00, $40.00

  • About This Book
  • Reviews
  • Author Information
  • Series
  • Table of Contents
  • Links

About This Book

Reaganism is a discourse of devotion and disqualification, combining a neoliberal negative theology of the market with a neoconservative demonization of opponents. By representing the market as a moralistic standard of perfection, a representation of goodness and freedom, Reagan’s personality cult organizes a social fantasy that shelters from inquiry the aggressivity of the market as a war of all against all. In literary theory and criticism, a homologous valuative system centered itself on the canon, which covers for exclusionary social systems by representing them as devoted agents of culture, defined as the Arnoldian study of perfection. Paul de Man argued for the displacement of this positive moralism, critiquing its referential structure for its failure to account for the arbitrariness of signification. But de Man’s proposals ultimately replace the system of culture and canon with a negative moralism, centered on literariness defined as a negative referent, a representation of the impossibility of desire to achieve its aims. 

De Man’s premises have been perpetuated in subsequent theory by persistent misrecognitions of dialectic as suspicious hermeneutics, of materialism as reference to materiality, and of demands for democratic equity as identity politics. The book traces this motivated reasoning through misreadings of Eve Sedgwick’s critique of conspiracy theory and Edward Said’s “secular criticism,” we are led back to the unexamined premises of Paul de Man’s negative moralism and the opportunistic competition of academic careerism. Stephen Best and Sharon Marcus cite Sedgwick to propose “surface reading” as an alternative or supplement to the hermeneutics of suspicion. But in failing to acknowledge that Ricoeur’s definition of a method common to Marx, Nietzsche, and Freud in terms of suspicion is a form of “defining the opposition,” which constructs the other as a negative image of the self. Their theoretical blind spots are thus linked to political or historical blind spots, and their willingness to accept bad faith objectifications of opponents is linked to the interpretive structure of privilege, in which narcissism organizes and sanctions aggressivity.

Like Sedgwick, Edward Said interrogates the homologies among interpretive, political, and historical patterns of behaviour, discerning the implication of literary studies in the rise of Reaganism. His secular criticism proposes an alternative to Reagan’s devotion to markets as well as the humanities’ devotion to canon, but it is attacked by J. Hillis Miller and Stanley Fish as a form of referential moralism. This line of attack is predicated on de Man’s arguments for the impossibility of reference, read as an alibi for competition and opportunism. A new explanation for the connections between de Man’s literary theory and his opportunist collaboration with Belgium’s Nazi occupiers is suggested by his use of arbitrary signification to obviate solidarity and cooperation in many forms—whether it be truth as intersubjective verifiability, justice as coincidence of interests, or aesthetic harmony as the compatibility of diverse preferences. His arguments to replace logic with aesthetics as the primary criterion of judgment are homologous with the replacement of the rule of law with personal rule, an unprincipled opportunism demonstrated by both supremacist politics and market competition.

Reviews

No reviews for this title.

Author Information

Jeremiah Bowen, PhD is author of Reaganism in Literary Theory: Negative Moralism and Hermeneutic Suspicion and the book-length poems Consolations, and Argument on the Internet, volumes 1 and 2.

Series

Anthem symploke Studies in Theory

Table of Contents

Essay One. Interpretive Politics: Reading Systemic Oppressions with Eve Sedgwick, Stephen Best and Sharon Marcus; 1. Reading the Lines; 2. Paranoid Projects; 3. Defining the Opposition; Essay Two. Devotional Scholarship: Reading Academic Reaganism with Edward Said, Stanley Fish and Walter Jackson Bate; 1. Neoliberalism and Religious Intellectualism; 2. Neoconservatism as Negative Devotion; 3. Professional Privilege; Essay Three. Negative Moralism: Reading Literariness, Materiality and Revolution with Paul de Man and J. Hillis Miller; 1. The Disqualification of de Man; 2. Reference to Nothingness; 3. Misreading Materialism

Links

Latest Tweets

  • "Larry Barton delivers a major contribution to the literature with unrivalled wisdom. He is, without doubt, the lea… https://t.co/N53RQDpU6D

    - 03:36:45 on 11/07/2020
  • RT @MagdaRomanska: Happy to join the editorial board of Anthem Studies in #Theatre & #Performance @AnthemPress If you have a manuscript tha…

    - 03:36:45 on 11/07/2020
  • "Lessons from a mechanical maestro." We're happy to hear @PeterMarsh307 of @madeherenow enjoyed David Waller's IR… https://t.co/bHclUXuFOV

    - 03:36:45 on 10/07/2020
  • @uoregon Prof. and author @peterlaufer discusses the US/Mexico border in his forthcoming title UP AGAINST THE WALL:… https://t.co/0YCKdhrPwJ

    - 03:36:45 on 10/07/2020
  • "A methodological tour de force offering rich and compelling means to analyse, understand and demonstrate the… https://t.co/gG9NSwE5v8

    - 03:36:45 on 09/07/2020
  • "Why is Yoda green?" We're excited to announce that Dr. Tatiana Tiaynen-Qadir and Prof. Ali Qadir have begun their… https://t.co/ezqQFQBhZU

    - 03:36:45 on 08/07/2020
  • "A new #coldwar, between #China and the West, has become the most important consequence of #COVID-19." In the Anth… https://t.co/A7Flm3vS68

    - 03:36:45 on 08/07/2020
  • RT @ColetteGrace: We celebrate with @IdentityWoman as the @AmazonKindle edition, The Domains of Identity, in the Keith/Mazzucelli Ethics o…

    - 03:36:45 on 08/07/2020
  • "By combining together #Western and #Oriental modes of art, this study is not only aimed at filling a gap in… https://t.co/ETjZUtfCyu

    - 03:36:45 on 07/07/2020
  • "The entire study contains detailed and minute analysis of many poems of Pringle." Dhrubajyoti Banerjee reviews Ma… https://t.co/a2h07K0rPA

    - 03:36:45 on 07/07/2020

Comodo SSL